If you are looking for communion gift, either for boys or girls, then you should go to Personal Creations and browse through their items. The site has lot of variety of stuff for you to browse through. If you cannot decide which gift to select, then you can spend some time at the site and slowly go through the products selection. I am sure you can find something you like there. what is the best item to give as first communion gift? I also not sure, just check it out at Personal Creations.